This is not a controversial blog. If you come here looking for divisive views or contentious polemic then you will, by and large, be disappointed. I’m a simple man and my only aim is to bore you with harmless tales of my vegetable growing exploits.
This week, however, I tread on slightly crumblier soil. There may even be some offence caused. But first some scene setting.
I spent this afternoon tidying up in the garden. The Magnolia in the middle of the lawn has been dropping leaves for weeks and the borders are full of things that have been slowly dying for some time.
After only an hour I had 5 bin liners full of green waste sitting on the patio. Now what do to with them? And this is where I part company with some proper gardeners. I took them to the tip.
That’s right: I threw them away! I didn’t take them to the bottom of the garden, I didn’t put all that lovely organic matter, wet leaves, stalks, plants, on to my compost heap to continue the cycle of veggie life by making my own compost.
I don’t even have a compost heap!
I have come to the conclusion that making compost is a green sham. In my own experience – unscientific, I grant you – it takes approximately 17 years for garden waste to rot down into something that is remotely usable in the garden. During which time you will generate a further 1,347 bags of garden waste.
This would require a compost heap roughly the size of Belgium, along with several labourers to turn and dig over the compost to “speed” the transformation into compost.
Or you can take it to the tip, where it gets taken to a local farm and turned into compost which is them resold (I checked!) and buy some organic compost from the garden centre to use in the meantime. And that Belgium-sized corner of your garden that is now freed up can be used to grown some more vegetables!
Brilliant, n’est ce pas?!?!?
On the ipod while…um…looking after the environment: Johnny Cash / Forty shades of green. And all of them in a bin liner in the boot of the car.
November 22, 2009 at 9:56 pm
17 years? That’s overdoing the hyperbole. Bury it in the ground (along with your spuds or under your Berlotti beans – where it will help retain moisture) and believe you me they will disappear in a year and improve your soil and your crops.If you were to start a conventional compost heap, mixing the leaves in with vegetable trimings from your kitchen, then all you need is some brandling worms who will merrily process your waste matter into compost all the year around. I suggest you get one of those plastic dalek shaped plastic bins as a suitable home for them.
But if you are determined to throw out a resource and then buy it back with your hard earned cash – go ahead!
Suggested song for your Iplayer: “You Won’t Find Another Fool Like Me.” (Well you did say controversial. lol)
November 22, 2009 at 10:15 pm
You are, of course, wrong. Why, only yesterday I turned my heap for the very first time since we started it in the spring. And – while I wouldn’t lay claim to “gardeners’ black gold” just yet – it’s definitely cookin’. I’ll give you a sack for Christmas, eggshells optional.
November 23, 2009 at 11:06 am
To each their own, just sorry I don’t live next door to you as my modest 3ft x 9ft compost bin area (which is split into 3 equal parts) would happily gobble up your garden waste, which I could then spread onto my veg beds next spring, with no extra money coming out of my pocket either to buy compost to enrich my beds or to spend money on petrol to take the waste to the tip.
November 24, 2009 at 11:39 am
I made some leaf mulch and it did work. It really only took a year. Trust me, I was as shocked as the next person to have not created a sludge.
November 25, 2009 at 8:26 pm
Drooling, I’m with you! My compost bin is a disappointing slow burner. Apparently worms are the answer, but not sure their teeth will be sharp enough to get through the tree I put in there.
December 15, 2009 at 11:50 pm
“My whole life has been spent waiting for an epiphany, a manifestation of God’s presence, the kind of transcendent, magical experience that lets you see your place in the big picture. And that is what I had with my first compost heap. I love compost and I believe that composting can save not the entire world, but a good portion of it.”
–Bette Midler, in a Los Angeles Times interview